Skip to main content
BluINFO

Technology and Commercial Real Estate Partnership Agreement

Introduction

Purpose of the Agreement

This Partnership Agreement is entered into by and between BluB0X, a leading provider of innovative security and building management solutions, and [Real Estate Company Name], a distinguished entity in the commercial real estate sector. The primary purpose of this agreement is to establish a mutually beneficial partnership that leverages BluB0X’s cutting-edge technology, including its BluSKY platform and forthcoming products, to enhance the operational efficiency, security, and technological advancement of [Real Estate Company Name]'s properties.

By integrating BluB0X’s comprehensive suite of services – encompassing access control, video surveillance, visitor management, elevator control, intercom systems, and more – [Real Estate Company Name] aims to position itself at the forefront of technology-led real estate management. This agreement outlines the scope of the collaboration, detailing the exclusive use of BluB0X’s solutions, the roles and responsibilities of each party, financial arrangements including incentives and discounts, and collaborative efforts in product development and marketing.

Parties to the Agreement

  1. BluB0X: A pioneer in security and building management technology, BluB0X offers the BluSKY platform, an AI-based system designed to revolutionize building management. BluB0X’s commitment to innovation, customer satisfaction, and excellence positions it as a leader in the industry.
  2. [Real Estate Company Name]: With a portfolio that spans across [specify regions or notable properties], [Real Estate Company Name] is a respected name in commercial real estate, known for its dedication to providing high-quality, secure, and efficiently managed properties to its tenants and clients.

Collaborative Vision

The partnership envisages a dynamic collaboration where [Real Estate Company Name] adopts BluB0X’s BluSKY and future technological innovations as the exclusive solution for all its building management needs. This collaboration is not just transactional but strategic, aiming to set new standards in the commercial real estate industry by fully harnessing the potential of advanced technology.

The Promise of Innovation

BluB0X, through its BluSKY platform and the Building Oracle, promises to deliver an unparalleled level of integration, bringing together various building management systems into a cohesive, intelligent network. This integration will enable [Real Estate Company Name] to achieve new efficiencies, enhance security, and offer a superior experience to its tenants and clients. The Building Oracle, an AI-based system, will serve as a central hub for data and insights, driving informed decision-making and predictive management strategies.

Mutual Commitment

This agreement marks the beginning of a long-term partnership built on trust, innovation, and a shared vision for the future of commercial real estate. Both BluB0X and [Real Estate Company Name] commit to working collaboratively, ensuring that the technologies and services provided not only meet the current needs but also evolve to address future challenges and opportunities in the industry.

Scope of Partnership

Exclusive Use of BluSKY Platform

The cornerstone of this partnership is [Real Estate Company Name]'s commitment to exclusively utilize BluB0X’s BluSKY platform across its entire portfolio of properties. This encompasses all facets of building management technology, including but not limited to:

  • Access Control: Ensuring secure and efficient entry to the premises.
  • Video Surveillance: Advanced monitoring for safety and security.
  • Visitor Management: Streamlined processes for managing guests and temporary access.
  • Elevator Control: Optimized and secure elevator operations.
  • Intercom Systems: Integrated communication solutions.

In addition to these existing features, [Real Estate Company Name] will also adopt any future innovations developed by BluB0X, maintaining the status of a technology leader in the commercial real estate industry.

Integration and Expansion

A pivotal aspect of this partnership is the integration of BluSKY with [Real Estate Company Name]'s current operational infrastructure. BluB0X will work closely with [Real Estate Company Name] to ensure seamless integration, providing necessary support and expertise. This integration extends to all current and future properties managed by [Real Estate Company Name].

Moreover, the partnership is set to explore and expand into new realms of building management, such as space management, environmental controls, and energy efficiency solutions, all underpinned by the BluSKY platform.

The Building Oracle Initiative

Central to this collaboration is the development and implementation of the Building Oracle, an AI-driven system designed by BluB0X. This innovative system will absorb and analyze data from various sources, including security systems, personnel reports, and operational metrics, to provide actionable insights for enhancing building management.

The Building Oracle will serve as a decision-support tool, enabling [Real Estate Company Name] to make informed choices regarding security, operations, and tenant services. Its predictive capabilities will help in anticipating and mitigating potential issues before they arise, setting a new standard in proactive building management.

Future Development and Collaboration

This partnership is dynamic and forward-looking, with both parties committed to continuous collaboration in the development of new technologies and solutions. [Real Estate Company Name] will have the opportunity to provide input and feedback, ensuring that future developments of BluSKY and related products align with the evolving needs of the commercial real estate market.

Roles and Responsibilities

BluB0X’s Commitments:
  1. Technology Provision and Integration: BluB0X shall provide the BluSKY platform, including all its current functionalities and future enhancements. BluB0X will ensure the seamless integration of BluSKY with [Real Estate Company Name]'s existing systems and infrastructure. This includes access control, video surveillance, visitor management, elevator control, intercom systems, and any additional services as they are developed.
  2. Ongoing Support and Maintenance: BluB0X will offer comprehensive support and maintenance for BluSKY. This includes regular updates, troubleshooting, and technical assistance to ensure optimal performance and continuous improvement of the system.
  3. Dedicated Account Management: In response to [Real Estate Company Name]'s request for dedicated resources, BluB0X will provide a full-time account manager. This manager will serve as the primary contact point for all matters related to the partnership, offering personalized support, facilitating communication, and ensuring the highest level of service.
  4. Training and Educational Resources: BluB0X commits to providing thorough training for [Real Estate Company Name]’s staff on the BluSKY platform. This includes initial training sessions upon implementation and ongoing educational resources to keep the staff updated on new features and best practices.
  5. Collaborative Product Development: BluB0X values [Real Estate Company Name]'s insights and feedback on product development. BluB0X will involve [Real Estate Company Name] in the process of developing new features and enhancements, ensuring that the product evolution aligns with their needs and industry trends.

[Real Estate Company Name]’s Commitments:

  1. Exclusive Adoption of BluSKY: [Real Estate Company Name] agrees to exclusively use the BluSKY platform and future BluB0X technologies for all their building management needs across their entire property portfolio. This includes adopting new features and systems as they are developed by BluB0X.
  2. Feedback and Collaboration: [Real Estate Company Name] will actively provide feedback and collaborate with BluB0X on the development and enhancement of BluSKY. This includes participating in regular meetings to discuss performance, potential improvements, and future needs.
  3. Promotion and Case Studies: As part of the collaborative marketing efforts, [Real Estate Company Name] agrees to participate in joint case studies and white papers, showcasing the impact and benefits of BluSKY in their operations. They will also assist in promoting BluB0X as a technology leader in the commercial real estate sector.
  4. Compliance and Best Practices: [Real Estate Company Name] commits to adhering to all applicable laws and regulations in the implementation and use of BluSKY. They will also follow best practices recommended by BluB0X for optimal utilization of the technology.
  5. Financial Obligations: [Real Estate Company Name] will fulfill their financial obligations as outlined in the financial terms of this agreement, respecting the agreed-upon fee structure and payment schedules.

Financial Terms

BluSKY Fees and Discounts:

1. Regular Fees: [Real Estate Company Name] will be responsible for paying regular fees for the use of BluSKY and any other BluB0X products, as per the standard pricing model. This includes recurring charges for access to the platform and any additional services utilized.

2. Discount Structure: Recognizing the value of this strategic partnership, BluB0X will offer [Real Estate Company Name] a discounted pricing structure. The discount will apply to both recurring fees and one-time costs associated with the implementation of BluSKY and other BluB0X products. The discount rates are as follows:

  • Recurring Fees: A reduction of 5-15% on the standard fees for the BluSKY platform.
  • One-Time Costs: A reduction of 5-10% on the initial costs involved in the implementation and setup of BluSKY and related technologies.

3. Review of Financial Terms: The financial terms will be subject to an annual review to ensure they remain fair and relevant to the evolving nature of the partnership and market conditions. Adjustments, if any, will be made in mutual agreement.

Account Manager Cost Consideration:
  1. Dedicated Account Manager: In line with [Real Estate Company Name]'s request for a dedicated account manager, BluB0X will allocate a full-time resource to this role. The cost of this resource will be factored into the overall discount structure, balancing the additional service provision with financial feasibility.
  2. Cost Sharing: There will be an option to revisit the arrangement of the dedicated account manager, including a potential cost-sharing model, during the annual financial review.
Additional Financial Provisions:
  1. Payment Terms: Standard payment terms will apply to all charges, with [Real Estate Company Name] expected to adhere to timely payments as per the agreed-upon schedule.
  2. Incentives for Future Developments: [Real Estate Company Name] will benefit from preferential pricing on future BluB0X products and services, reflecting their status as a key strategic partner.
  3. Joint Marketing and Case Studies: Any joint marketing initiatives, such as case studies and white papers, will be funded by BluB0X.

Technology Integration and Data Sharing

Integration of BluSKY Platform:
  1.  Seamless Integration: BluB0X will ensure the smooth integration of the BluSKY platform with the existing infrastructure of [Real Estate Company Name]. This includes coordination with existing systems and ensuring compatibility with various building management functionalities.
  2. Customization: BluB0X will provide customized solutions as part of the BluSKY platform to meet the specific needs of [Real Estate Company Name]'s properties. These customizations will aim to optimize the operational efficiency and user experience of the platform.
  3. Upgrades and Enhancements: BluB0X will regularly update the BluSKY platform, ensuring that [Real Estate Company Name] benefits from the latest technological advancements. This includes adding new features and improving existing ones in response to feedback and market trends.

Data Sharing and Management:

  1. Data Collection and Usage: The partnership will involve extensive data collection from various sources, including security systems, operational metrics, and user feedback. BluB0X will manage and analyze this data to enhance the functionality of BluSKY and the Building Oracle.
  2. Data Privacy and Security: Both parties commit to upholding the highest standards of data privacy and security. BluB0X will implement robust security measures to protect sensitive information and comply with relevant data protection regulations.
  3. Insights and Reports: BluB0X will provide [Real Estate Company Name] with regular insights and reports generated from the data analysis. These reports will be instrumental in informed decision-making, predictive maintenance, and enhancing overall building management.

Collaboration in Data-Driven Innovations:

  1. Feedback Loop: [Real Estate Company Name] will have an ongoing opportunity to provide feedback on the data management and analytics capabilities of BluSKY. This feedback will be critical in continuously improving and customizing the data solutions offered.
  2. Joint Development Initiatives: BluB0X and [Real Estate Company Name] will engage in joint initiatives to explore new data-driven technologies and applications. This collaborative approach aims to leverage the full potential of the data collected to innovate in the field of building management.

Operational Collaboration and Support

Operational Collaboration:
  1. Joint Planning and Execution: BluB0X and [Real Estate Company Name] will engage in joint planning sessions to ensure the operational objectives of both parties are aligned and integrated effectively with the BluSKY platform. This includes setting timelines, defining key performance indicators, and establishing operational benchmarks.
  2. Customized Operational Solutions: BluB0X will work closely with [Real Estate Company Name] to understand their unique operational challenges and tailor the BluSKY platform to address these challenges, enhancing operational efficiency and tenant satisfaction.
  3. Innovation in Building Operations: Both parties will explore innovative approaches to building management, leveraging BluSKY’s capabilities to improve services such as space management, energy efficiency, and tenant engagement.

Support and Maintenance:

  1. Dedicated Support: BluB0X will provide dedicated support through the assigned account manager, who will be responsible for addressing any operational challenges faced by [Real Estate Company Name] in using BluSKY.
  2. Regular Maintenance and Updates: BluB0X will ensure regular maintenance and updates of the BluSKY platform, keeping it at the forefront of technology and operational effectiveness.
  3. Emergency Response: BluB0X will establish protocols for emergency response, ensuring swift action in case of any critical issues with the BluSKY platform.

Training and Capacity Building:

  1. Staff Training: BluB0X will provide comprehensive training for [Real Estate Company Name]'s staff on the BluSKY platform. This training will be tailored to different user levels, from general users to technical staff.
  2. Ongoing Learning Resources: BluB0X will supply ongoing learning materials and updates to [Real Estate Company Name]'s staff, ensuring they remain proficient in the latest functionalities of BluSKY.
  3. Feedback and Improvement Sessions: Regular feedback sessions will be conducted to assess the training needs and continuously improve the capacity building process.

Collaborative Improvement Efforts:

  1. Continuous Improvement Process: BluB0X and [Real Estate Company Name] will engage in a continuous improvement process, routinely reviewing operational metrics to identify areas for enhancement.
  2. Innovation Workshops: Periodic workshops will be held to brainstorm new ideas and potential improvements in operational practices, facilitated by the insights gained from BluSKY.

Product Development and Feedback

Innovative Product Development:
  1. Collaborative Innovation: BluB0X and [Real Estate Company Name] will collaborate on the development of new features and products. This collaboration aims to ensure that the evolving needs of the commercial real estate market are met with innovative, effective solutions.
  2. Roadmap Planning: Both parties will participate in regular roadmap planning sessions to discuss and prioritize future enhancements and new product developments. This will include setting timelines and allocating resources for development initiatives.
  3. Beta Testing and Early Access: [Real Estate Company Name] will have the opportunity to participate in beta testing of new features and products, providing valuable feedback before full market release.

Feedback Mechanisms:

  1. Regular Feedback Sessions: BluB0X will organize regular sessions with [Real Estate Company Name] to gather feedback on the performance and usability of BluSKY and other products. This feedback will be integral to continuous improvement.
  2. User Experience Surveys: BluB0X will conduct periodic surveys among [Real Estate Company Name]'s staff and tenants to gather broader feedback on the user experience and areas for enhancement.
  3. Issue Resolution and Enhancement Requests: A dedicated channel will be established for [Real Estate Company Name] to report issues and request enhancements. BluB0X will prioritize these inputs in its development cycle.
  4. Product Evolution Participation:
  5. Advisory Role: [Real Estate Company Name] will have an advisory role in the product development process, offering insights and suggestions based on their operational experience and market knowledge.
  6. Focus Groups: BluB0X will involve [Real Estate Company Name] in focus groups, providing a platform for in-depth discussions on product evolution, new features, and market trends.
  7. Technology Workshops: Regular technology workshops will be held to discuss emerging technologies, potential applications in the real estate sector, and how they can be integrated into BluB0X’s offerings.

Marketing and Branding Collaboration

Joint Marketing Initiatives:
  1. Case Studies and White Papers: BluB0X and [Real Estate Company Name] will collaborate on creating case studies and white papers. These documents will highlight the effectiveness of BluSKY in improving building operations, showcasing innovative uses, and demonstrating the tangible benefits to tenants and property management.
  2. Co-Branding Opportunities: Opportunities for co-branding will be explored, where both BluB0X and [Real Estate Company Name] can jointly participate in marketing activities. This includes industry events, trade shows, and promotional materials.
  3. Press Releases and Media Engagement: Joint press releases and media engagements will be organized to announce significant milestones, new initiatives, or success stories stemming from the partnership.
Promotional Activities:
  1. Showcasing Technology Leadership: [Real Estate Company Name] will be featured in BluB0X’s promotional materials as a leading example of a technology-forward real estate company. This will enhance their market positioning and attract tech-savvy tenants.
  2. Social Media and Online Marketing: Both parties will engage in social media and online marketing campaigns to promote the partnership, the innovative use of BluSKY, and the benefits of technology in real estate.
  3. Testimonials and Endorsements: [Real Estate Company Name] will provide testimonials and endorsements for BluSKY, which can be used in various marketing channels to build credibility and trust among potential customers.
Market Insight and Development:
  1. Market Research Collaboration: BluB0X and [Real Estate Company Name] will collaborate on market research activities to understand emerging trends, tenant preferences, and new market opportunities.
  2. Feedback on Marketing Strategies: [Real Estate Company Name] will provide feedback on BluB0X’s marketing strategies, ensuring they are aligned with the real estate market's dynamics and customer expectations.
  3. Strategy Workshops: Regular strategy workshops will be conducted to align marketing efforts, discuss new ideas, and plan future campaigns.

Legal and Compliance

Compliance with Laws and Regulations:
  1. Adherence to Legal Standards: Both BluB0X and [Real Estate Company Name] commit to complying with all applicable laws and regulations in their operations and in the implementation of the BluSKY platform. This includes, but is not limited to, data protection laws, safety standards, and industry-specific regulations.
  2. Updates on Legal Changes: Both parties will keep each other informed about any changes in legal standards that may affect the partnership or the use of BluSKY. Proactive adjustments will be made to ensure continuous compliance.
Intellectual Property Rights:
  1. Ownership of Developments: BluB0Xwill retain full and complete ownership of any new intellectual property developed as a result of the partnership. This includes innovations in software, systems, and processes.
  2. Licensing and Usage: [Real Estate Company Name] will be granted a license to use BluB0X’s intellectual property, including BluSKY and any future developments, exclusively for their operations.
Confidentiality and Non-Disclosure:
  1. Protection of Sensitive Information: Both parties agree to protect and keep confidential any sensitive information shared during the course of the partnership. This includes proprietary information, trade secrets, and any data related to tenants or operations.
  2. Non-Disclosure Agreement (NDA): A mutual NDA will be part of the agreement, specifying the scope, duration, and terms of confidentiality.
Liability and Indemnification:
  1. Limitation of Liability: The agreement will define the limitations of liability for both BluB0X and [Real Estate Company Name]. This includes provisions for any potential issues arising from the use of BluSKY or associated technologies.
  2. Indemnification Clauses: Indemnification clauses will be included to protect each party from liabilities arising from the other party's actions or breaches of the agreement.
Dispute Resolution:
  1. Mechanism for Dispute Resolution: The agreement will establish a clear mechanism for resolving any disputes that might arise between BluB0X and [Real Estate Company Name], including mediation and arbitration processes.
  2. Jurisdiction and Governing Law: The agreement will specify the jurisdiction and the governing law under which any legal disputes will be resolved.

Performance Metrics and Goals

Establishing Performance Metrics:
  1. Key Performance Indicators (KPIs): BluB0X and [Real Estate Company Name] will collaboratively establish clear KPIs to measure the performance and impact of the BluSKY platform within [Real Estate Company Name]'s operations. These metrics may include system uptime, user satisfaction, efficiency improvements, and cost savings.
  2. Data-Driven Analysis: The partnership will utilize data collected from BluSKY and the Building Oracle to conduct regular analyses, assessing performance against the established KPIs.
  3. Customized Metrics: Given the diverse nature of [Real Estate Company Name]'s properties, customized metrics may be developed for different property types or operational scenarios, ensuring a comprehensive assessment.
Setting and Reviewing Goals:
  1. Joint Goal Setting: Goals for the partnership will be set jointly, aligning with both BluB0X’s vision for technology innovation and [Real Estate Company Name]'s operational objectives. These goals will be revisited and revised periodically to remain relevant and challenging.
  2. Strategic Objectives: The goals will encompass various aspects of the partnership, including technological integration, operational efficiency, tenant satisfaction, and market leadership in technology adoption.
  3. Long-Term Vision: Both parties will also establish long-term goals, looking beyond immediate operational needs to the broader impact on the commercial real estate market and technological advancements.
Regular Performance Reviews:
  1. Scheduled Reviews: BluB0X and [Real Estate Company Name] will conduct regular performance reviews, using the established KPIs and goals as benchmarks. These reviews will serve as opportunities for open dialogue and feedback.
  2. Continuous Improvement: Insights gained from these reviews will feed into a continuous improvement process, with both parties committed to making necessary adjustments to strategies, operations, and the BluSKY platform.
  3. Report Generation: Regular reports will be generated and shared between both parties, documenting performance metrics, goal progress, and any recommendations for improvement.

Duration, Review, and Termination

Duration of the Agreement:
  1. Initial Term: The initial term of the partnership will be set for three years, starting from the effective date of the agreement. This term reflects the commitment of both parties to a long-term collaboration.
  2. Renewal Options: Upon nearing the end of the initial term, both parties will have the option to renew the agreement. The terms of renewal, including any modifications or updates to the agreement, will be mutually discussed, and agreed upon.
Regular Review of the Agreement:
  1. Annual Reviews: The partnership agreement will be subject to an annual review. This review will assess the overall performance, satisfaction of both parties, and relevance of the terms in the current market context.
  2. Adjustments and Amendments: Based on the annual review, both parties may agree to make adjustments or amendments to the agreement. These changes would aim to enhance the partnership's effectiveness and address any new challenges or opportunities.
Termination Clauses:
  1. Termination by Mutual Agreement: The agreement can be terminated by mutual consent of both parties if it is deemed that the partnership is no longer beneficial or viable.
  2. Termination for Cause: This agreement may be terminated for cause, such as breach of contract, failure to meet agreed-upon KPIs, or other significant issues.
  3. Notice Period and Procedures: The agreement requires a 30 day notice period and procedures for termination, ensuring an orderly and professional conclusion of the partnership, if necessary.
  4. Post-Termination Obligations: Responsibilities and obligations of both parties post-termination include the handling of shared data, confidentiality, and any remaining financial obligations.

Final Provisions:

  1. Documentation and Record Keeping: Both parties will maintain proper documentation and records throughout the duration of the partnership, ensuring transparency and accountability.
  2. Effective Date: The agreement is effective __________________, marking the commencement of the partnership.

Dispute Resolution

Mechanisms for Resolving Disputes:
  1. Initial Resolution Efforts: In the event of a dispute, both BluB0X and [Real Estate Company Name] agree to first attempt to resolve the issue through direct communication and negotiation. This approach favors a quick and amicable resolution, maintaining the partnership's integrity.
  2. Escalation Procedures: If initial efforts do not resolve the dispute, the issue will be escalated to higher management within both organizations. This step ensures that senior-level attention is given to finding a resolution.
  3. Mediation: Should escalated negotiations fail to resolve the dispute, both parties agree to engage in mediation. A neutral third-party mediator will be involved to facilitate discussions and assist in reaching a mutually acceptable solution.
Arbitration Clause:
  1. Binding Arbitration: If mediation does not lead to a resolution, the dispute will be subject to binding arbitration. Both parties agree to abide by the decision of the arbitrator.
  2. Arbitration Process: The arbitration process will be conducted in accordance with agreed-upon rules and procedures. This ensures a fair and objective resolution.
  3. Confidentiality in Arbitration: All arbitration proceedings will be confidential, protecting the interests and reputations of both parties.
Legal Recourse:
  1. Limitation on Litigation: The agreement will encourage resolving disputes through the outlined mechanisms, with litigation as a last resort. This clause is intended to minimize legal costs and maintain a cooperative relationship.
  2. Jurisdiction and Governing Law: In cases where litigation becomes necessary, the agreement will specify the jurisdiction and governing law applicable to the dispute.
Recording and Learning from Disputes:
  1. Documentation of Disputes: All disputes and the outcomes of resolution processes will be documented. This record-keeping will be useful for learning and improving future interactions and processes.
  2. Feedback and Improvement: Lessons learned from dispute resolutions will be discussed and used as feedback for improving the partnership's operational and communication strategies.

Final Provisions

Documentation and Record-Keeping:
  1. Accurate Records: Both BluB0X and [Real Estate Company Name] will maintain accurate and detailed records related to the partnership. This includes documentation of services provided, financial transactions, communication logs, and dispute resolutions.
  2. Confidentiality of Records: All records and documentation related to the partnership will be treated as confidential and will be protected accordingly.
Amendments and Modifications:
  1. Procedure for Amendments: The agreement may be amended or modified only by a written document signed by duly authorized representatives of both BluB0X and [Real Estate Company Name].
  2. Flexibility for Changes: Both parties acknowledge that the business environment is dynamic, and therefore, provisions for flexible amendments are included to accommodate changes in circumstances, technology, and market conditions.
Representations and Warranties:
  1. Mutual Representations: Both parties will provide representations and warranties confirming their authority to enter into the agreement and the accuracy of their commitments.
  2. Disclaimer of Additional Warranties: Except for the expressed warranties in the agreement, both parties disclaim any additional warranties, either expressed or implied.
Notices:
  1. Method of Communication: All notices, requests, and other communications required or permitted under this agreement must be in writing and sent to designated representatives of BluB0X and [Real Estate Company Name].
  2. Acknowledgment of Receipt: A procedure for acknowledging the receipt of communications will be established, ensuring that all important information is received and processed.
Entire Agreement:
  1. Superseding Document: This agreement constitutes the entire agreement between BluB0X and [Real Estate Company Name] concerning the subject matter, superseding all prior agreements, understandings, negotiations, and discussions, whether oral or written.
  2. No Reliance on Unstated Assumptions: Both parties acknowledge that they have not relied on any statement, promise, or representation not explicitly set forth in this agreement.
Severability:
  1. Validity of Remaining Provisions: If any provision of this agreement is held to be invalid or unenforceable, the remaining provisions will continue to be valid and enforceable to the fullest extent permitted by law.

Agreed to By:

BluB0X:

 

Name:

Title:

Signature:

Date:

 

[Real Estate Company Name]:

 

Name:

Title:

Signature:

Date:

  • Was this article helpful?